Over spot means the amount you pay above the spot price for your silver. Spot is the market price of one troy ounce of silver as raw metal. No dealer sells a finished coin, round or bar at spot, because making the piece, shipping it to the dealer and running the shop all cost money, and that cost plus the dealer margin rides on top of spot. When a listing says a round is $4.00 over spot, it means the price of that round is the spot price plus $4.00 for each troy ounce. The phrase is a reading tool. Once you can read it, you can compare two listings in seconds, even when the dealers quote their prices in different ways.
Dealers quote the same gap in three forms, and a buyer needs to be able to move between all three. The first form is dollars over spot per troy ounce, such as $4.00 over spot. The second form is a percent over spot, such as 10 percent over spot. The third form hides the gap: the listing shows only the total price, and you work the gap out yourself by taking the spot price away from the price you would pay. All three forms describe the same thing, the distance between the value of the metal and the price of the piece in your hand.
Worked example
Say spot is $40.00 per troy ounce. That figure is a round teaching price, not a live quote. Three listings sit side by side at a dealer, and each one quotes the gap in a different form.
- A one troy ounce generic round at $4.00 over spot. The price is $40.00 + $4.00 = $44.00. As a percent, the gap is $4.00 ÷ $40.00 = 0.10, which is 10 percent over spot.
- A one troy ounce government coin at $8.00 over spot. The price is $40.00 + $8.00 = $48.00. As a percent, the gap is $8.00 ÷ $40.00 = 0.20, which is 20 percent over spot. The coin costs $48.00 − $44.00 = $4.00 more than the round for the same one troy ounce of silver, and that extra $4.00 buys the mint name and the wider recognition that comes with it.
- A ten troy ounce bar at $2.00 over spot per troy ounce. The price per troy ounce is $40.00 + $2.00 = $42.00, and the price of the whole bar is 10 × $42.00 = $420.00. Check the gap two ways. The spot value of the metal is 10 × $40.00 = $400.00, so the total amount over spot is $420.00 − $400.00 = $20.00. Per troy ounce that is 10 × $2.00 = $20.00, and the two answers agree. As a percent, the gap is $2.00 ÷ $40.00 = 0.05, which is 5 percent over spot, the lowest of the three listings, because the cost of making one large piece spreads across ten troy ounces.
One more step shows why the listing figure is not the end of the story. Say you buy a single round from the first listing and pay $10.00 in shipping. Your all in cost is $44.00 + $10.00 = $54.00 for one troy ounce, so the amount you truly paid over spot is $54.00 − $40.00 = $14.00, which is $14.00 ÷ $40.00 = 0.35, or 35 percent over spot. The listing said $4.00 over spot, and the listing was honest. Shipping is simply a part of your cost that the listing figure never claimed to hold, and on a small order it can grow the true gap by more than the premium itself.
Run your own numbers
Open the free Silver DCA Calculator on the homepage. The spot price on the page is live, and the calculator and the portfolio tracker work from the total you paid and the troy ounces you bought. Add a purchase with the total from your receipt, shipping inside it, and the calculator shows your average cost per troy ounce. Take the live spot price away from that average and what remains is your all in amount over spot for that buy, in dollars per troy ounce. Divide that remainder by the live spot price and you have the same gap as a percent. Run that short check on any order, new or old, and a listing that looked cheap and a listing that looked dear often change places once shipping joins the maths.
Mistakes to avoid
- 1. Comparing a dollars over quote with a percent over quote without converting. $4.00 over spot and 10 percent over spot are the same gap at a $40.00 spot price, as the example shows, but they drift apart as spot moves. At a higher spot price the same $4.00 is a smaller percent, and at a lower spot price it is a larger one. Convert every quote to the same form before you judge it.
- 2. Treating the listing figure as your all in figure. The amount over spot on a product page covers the piece itself. Shipping, card fees and any other charge at checkout sit outside it, and on a one ounce order they can outweigh the premium. Judge every buy on the total that leaves your account.
- 3. Assuming the lowest amount over spot is always the best buy. A large bar often carries the lowest gap per troy ounce, and it also ties up the most money in one piece and can be harder to sell in part later. A coin with a higher gap may sell faster and to more buyers. The gap is one fact about a purchase, not the whole of it.
- 4. Reading the gap once and never again. Spot moves all day, and a price that was $4.00 over spot in the morning can be a different amount over spot by the evening if the dealer price stays still while spot moves, or the other way around. Check the gap at the moment you order, with the spot price of that moment.
Variations to try
- Compare the same piece at more than one dealer. Take one round or one bar that several dealers stock, convert each listing to dollars over spot with the same live spot price, then add shipping for your order size at each dealer. The winner on the product page is not always the winner at checkout.
- Move up in size when the savings are real. Bigger bars tend to carry a lower amount over spot per troy ounce, as the bar in the example shows at 5 percent against 10 percent for the round. Weigh that saving against the larger single spend and the loss of the option to sell a small part of the stack at a time.
- Keep your routine and watch the gap as you go. A dollar cost averaging routine buys on a schedule rather than on a forecast, and the amount over spot is the part of the price you can shop around on each buy. Note the gap for each purchase in your records, next to the total and the ounces, and over a year you will see what you truly pay above spot to build your stack, and which dealer and which form of silver treat your routine best.
Want your own average worked out? The free Silver DCA Calculator on the homepage blends your purchases into one average cost per ounce and tracks your profit and loss at the live spot price, your portfolio stays in your own browser, nothing is uploaded.
Open the calculator
