You can plan your next silver buy to hit a target average cost, and the maths needs only three figures you already hold. The first figure is your current stack, how many troy ounces you hold and what you paid for them in total. The second figure is the target average you want to reach, in dollars per troy ounce. The third figure is the all in price per troy ounce of the next buy, with shipping and any fees inside it. When the price of the next buy sits below your target, each new ounce pulls your average down toward that target, and the size of the buy decides how far it pulls. This post shows how to work out that size before you spend anything. It is general information about how the arithmetic works, not a recommendation to buy or to chase any particular average.
The idea rests on one plain fact. Your average cost is always your total spent divided by your total ounces. A new buy changes both sides of that division at once. It adds its cost to the total spent and it adds its ounces to the total ounces. Planning a buy is simply choosing the ounces so that the new division lands on the number you want.
Worked example
Say you hold 10 troy ounces and you paid $420.00 for them in total. Your current average is $420.00 ÷ 10 = $42.00 per troy ounce. Say your target average is $40.00 per troy ounce, and say the next buy on offer costs $35.00 per troy ounce all in. Those prices are round teaching figures, not live quotes. The question is simple. How many troy ounces at $35.00 do you need to add so that the new average is exactly $40.00?
The gap method answers it in two short steps.
- Step one, work out how far your current stack sits above the target. Each of your 10 troy ounces cost $42.00 − $40.00 = $2.00 above the target. Across the whole stack that gap is 10 × $2.00 = $20.00 above the target line.
- Step two, work out how far each new ounce sits below the target. Each new ounce costs $40.00 − $35.00 = $5.00 below the target. Each new ounce therefore covers $5.00 of the $20.00 gap.
- Step three, divide the gap by the cover. $20.00 ÷ $5.00 = 4 troy ounces. That is the size of buy the plan calls for, and it costs 4 × $35.00 = $140.00.
Now check the plan the direct way, with the totals. Add the buy to the stack: ounces 10 + 4 = 14 troy ounces, spent $420.00 + $140.00 = $560.00, and the new average is $560.00 ÷ 14 = $40.00 per troy ounce. The plan lands exactly on the target. A second check agrees: 14 × $40.00 = $560.00, which matches the total spent to the cent.
A trial check shows why the size matters. Say you bought only 2 troy ounces at $35.00 instead. The cost is 2 × $35.00 = $70.00, the new totals are $420.00 + $70.00 = $490.00 across 10 + 2 = 12 troy ounces, and the new average is $490.00 ÷ 12 = $40.83 per troy ounce after rounding. You moved closer to the target, from $42.00 to $40.83, but you did not reach it, because 2 ounces cover only 2 × $5.00 = $10.00 of the $20.00 gap. Half the gap needs half the ounces, and the full gap needs the full 4 ounces.
Run your own numbers
Open the free Silver DCA Calculator on the homepage. Add your past purchases to the portfolio tracker, using the total from each receipt, and the tracker shows your current total ounces, your total spent and your average cost per troy ounce at the live spot price. That average is your starting figure. Pick a target average below it, then add a trial purchase for the next buy you are considering, with its all in total and its ounces, and watch the average move. Adjust the ounces in the trial entry until the average on screen matches your target. The ounces in that final trial entry are the size your plan calls for at that price. If the dealer price changes, change the trial total and run the check again, because the size that works at one price will not work at another. Your entries stay in your own browser and on your own device; nothing is uploaded.
Mistakes to avoid
- 1. Planning with the spot price instead of the all in price. The average you live with is built from what you paid, not from spot. A buy planned at spot will land above the target once the premium and shipping join the total, every time. Work out the price per troy ounce from the full amount that would leave your account, then plan with that figure.
- 2. Trying to pull an average down with a buy that sits above the target. A new buy can only pull your average toward its own price. If the next buy costs $45.00 per troy ounce, it pulls an average of $42.00 upward, not downward. The check is short: 5 troy ounces at $45.00 cost $225.00, the totals become $420.00 + $225.00 = $645.00 across 15 troy ounces, and the average is $645.00 ÷ 15 = $43.00 per troy ounce. No size of buy at $45.00 can produce a $40.00 average.
- 3. Expecting a small buy to do a large job. The further your target sits from your current average, the more ounces the plan needs at a given price. The gap method shows the size plainly before you spend, and a plan that calls for more ounces than your budget holds is a plan to set aside or to soften with a nearer target, not a plan to force with money you need elsewhere.
- 4. Treating a target average as a goal worth any spend. A lower average is a nicer looking number, and that is all it is. It does not change what the silver is worth, and it does not turn a buy you cannot afford into a sound one. Plan the size with the maths, then judge the spend itself on your own budget and your own routine, the same as any other buy.
Variations to try
- Aim for a nearer target. A target of $41.00 needs a smaller buy than a target of $40.00 at the same next price. The gap is 10 × ($42.00 − $41.00) = $10.00, and each ounce at $35.00 covers $41.00 − $35.00 = $6.00, so $10.00 ÷ $6.00 = 1.67 troy ounces after rounding. A buy of 2 troy ounces costs $70.00 and gives an average of $490.00 ÷ 12 = $40.83 per troy ounce, which passes the $41.00 target with a little room to spare.
- Plan from a fixed spend instead. Turn the question around. Say you have $140.00 set aside and the all in price is $35.00 per troy ounce. The spend buys $140.00 ÷ $35.00 = 4 troy ounces, and the worked example already shows where that lands: a $40.00 average on a 14 troy ounce stack. A fixed spend and a target average are two views of the same plan, and checking both views takes under a minute.
- Run the plan again when the price moves. Say the next buy price rises to $38.00 per troy ounce before you order. The gap to a $40.00 target is still $20.00, but each ounce now covers only $40.00 − $38.00 = $2.00, so the plan calls for $20.00 ÷ $2.00 = 10 troy ounces, costing 10 × $38.00 = $380.00. The check agrees: $420.00 + $380.00 = $800.00 across 20 troy ounces is $800.00 ÷ 20 = $40.00 per troy ounce. A price closer to the target needs a larger buy to do the same work, and seeing that in the numbers helps you decide whether the plan still suits your routine or whether a nearer target serves you better.
Want your own average worked out? The free Silver DCA Calculator on the homepage blends your purchases into one average cost per ounce and tracks your profit and loss at the live spot price, your portfolio stays in your own browser, nothing is uploaded.
Open the calculator
